Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Blogging

I have been advised that I should 'tighten up' my blog. I should state (somewhere) just exactly what my blog is about. I should set a schedule when I will post new material to my blog. I should have information about me on my blog, so that people can tell if I am someone that they can relate to or not. I should decide who I want my readers to be and I should direct my posts to them.

Things that make you go, "Hmmm."

I really don't feel the need to state what my blog is about--really, I did that in one of my first posts, it is about whatever I happen to feel a need to talk about whenever it is that I post. I'm tempted to say that it's kind of like the 'Seinfeld' show, but then some idiot would think that my blog is about 'Seinfeld' and then he would get very disappointed when he finds only this one reference to that show.

When do I post? The plan is, every weekday. If you look back, you will find that I have missed a few deadlines (deadlines amuse me). I think one week I only posted once out of the five workdays (actually, that was Memorial Day week, so there were only 4 work days). I've been getting better, though; I think blogging is becoming more a part of my routine.

I don't think that I can write a terse summary of myself and have it convey who I am. Remember that old bumper sticker song? The verses were just recitations of clever bumper stickers, but the chorus said something about "There's no way you can tell the world exactly who you are, with a two-bit bumper sticker on your car." I'm probably misremembering that somewhat, but you get the idea. I can't sum up me in one paragraph. I tell you what though, the most important thing to me is God. I am a Christian. That doesn't mean that every day I'm going to go on some religious tirade. Look back through my past blogs. I did post a Bible study once, and I have made references to scripture a couple of other times, but I'm not looking to shove anything down anyone's throat. It's available if you're interested. If you're not interested, that's okay. I'm not going to offended if you 'change the channel.' I am a Navy veteran--I served for ten years and got out. Partly because I didn't feel that God's calling on my life included serving any more, but also because I just plain didn't want to go back to sea. I was an Electronics Technician in the Navy, and I am currently employed teaching electronics. Sort of. Maybe someday, I'll tell you more about that. I grew up in Georgia, but I haven't lived in Georgia in a while. I actually grew up in the suburbs of Atlanta, in an upper middle class home. I didn't even see a trailer park until I was a teenager (are there trailer parks in Georgia? Oh, yeah). To be honest, I lived in an upper middle class home, but we lived on a lower middle class income. Now I think that my parents were earning an upper middle class income, but, as a kid, I always thought that we had just managed to squeak into the neighborhood we were in. All the other kids seemed to have nicer stuff than we did. What I didn't understand, then, was the my parents lived through the Great Depression. They lived within their means. In fact, we lived well within their means--they kept putting money aside just in case. They live a very comfortable life, now. My parents were, I think, the oldest parents in our neighborhood. The rest of the families lived beyond their means, as is now common. I don't think any of them are nearly so comfortable, now. I wish that I had learned more from them about financial planning. Really, though, if you want to know who I am, just keep reading this blog. It's bound to come out, some time.

Who am I blogging for? Let's be honest. I'm blogging for me. If you happen to be like me, you may appreciate some or all of what I post on my blogs, but I'm a pretty unique individual, so there may not be too many people enough like me to appreciate my posts. That's okay. Alternatively, you may be completely different from me and want to read my posts just so that you can form arguments. That's okay, too. Evidently there aren't too many of you, either, because I have yet to receive even one negative comment. Not that I've received very many positive comments either...

Also, I signed up for Google's AdSense, and in their terms of service, they say that I can't have drugs or paraphernalia on my site (not even tobacco products). I don't really have a problem with that, I don't use tobacco or illegal drugs, but I have talked about tobacco, drugs, and paraphernalia. I don't think that's what they mean, though. If that is what they mean, then I will probably get a nasty-gram from them soon. It's not like I have pictures, or am promoting the use, of drugs, you know?

Tuesday, June 12, 2007

Animal Testing

I was just reading about the animal testing for stem-cell research in fighting Parkinson's disease. It shows a lot of promise, but it got me thinking about certain groups that oppose animal testing, and their logic (or lack thereof).



One of the big arguments used against animal testing is that Thalidomide was not found to cause birth defects during the testing process. That is completely true. Usually, the argument continues that the reason Thalidomide was approved by the FDA was because the animals used in testing were so dissimilar to humans that the animal testing indicated that Thalidomide was perfectly safe when used to prevent 'morning sickness.' Let's examine that claim.


First of all, Thalidomide was not developed as a 'morning sickness' pill. It was developed as a sleeping aid. It was tested as such.


Secondly, as far as the animals being too dissimilar to human beings, after the animal testing is completed, there is at least one round of 'human trials' before a drug can be brought to market (in both the US and the UK). So why didn't the UK human trials result in birth defects? Because they never tested it on pregnant women (or animals, for that matter). Some women who were prescribed Thalidomide became pregnant and continued to take the drug (after all, they didn't know that they shouldn't). Part of the problem was that Thalidomide really was an effective 'morning sickness' pill. When women found out that they were pregnant, and hadn't suffered from the usual nausea in the AM, word got around. Now, I don't pretend to know what British law says on the subject, but in the US, if a product has been tested safe, and then it is determined that said product is also effective in treating other ailments, it does not have to go through clinical trials again. Most of the time, this is reasonable. Minoxidil was a blood-pressure medicine that was also found to be effective, in some instances, for treating male-pattern baldness. In the case of Thalidomide, this was not reasonable. As it turns out, the pill cured 'morning sickness' by radically altering the developmental cycle of the fetus--causing birth defects. After word got around that these birth defects were happening, the researchers went back and test it on pregnant animals. Guess what happened? Birth defects.


Thirdly, The FDA did not approve it. There were two reasons for this: 1) the clinical trials indicated that although the drug caused no side effects in animals, it also did not make them sleepy (the fact that a drug was being marketed that had undergone animal testing but did not have the desired effect on animals raised a red flag), and 2) it had not been tested on pregnant subjects . The UK National Health Services approved it, as did the equivalent agencies in several other European countries.


For what it's worth, it was not actually FDA policy at the time to insist on pharmaceutical testing using pregnant subjects, but the doctor that was assigned to the Thalidomide case, Dr. Frances Oldham Kelsey, had studied Quinine in the 40's (Quinine is a drug used to treat malaria that has also been known to cause birth defects when taken by pregnant women). FDA policy changed on October 10th, 1962, when President Kennedy signed a bill extending the powers of the FDA and requiring more rigorous testing--thanks to Thalidomide.


I believe in animal testing--at least, as a precursor to human testing. I do think that sometimes lab animals get mistreated, and I think that is wrong. I mean, think about it, if you're testing to see if Rhyzomapan is safe, but then you're mistreating the lab animals, and they all die; is Rhyzomapan the problem, or is it just the way the animals are being treated?

(In)justice

Yesterday I promised to talk about Tommy Chong's jail sentence for misdemeanor possession. I think by now everyone who cares knows the story, but here it is anyway:

Belay that, I just did a little research to make sure I had my facts straight, and I wasn't even close. What I had heard was that TC had gotten busted for misdemeanor possession, along with several other people. All of then were first-offenders, but that he was the only one who got jail time. That's what I had heard. In actuality, he could have gotten busted for possession, but they didn't bother. They busted him for selling paraphernalia through an Internet/mail order business. Out of all the people that got busted--several different companies went down that day--he got the longest jail sentence. Some have said he got the only jail sentence, but, no, he just got the longest.
Now, what I was going to say, was that if several different people get busted for the same crime, but one of them has made a lot of money making fun of that exact crime--in fact, Cheech & Chong's records and movies make it pretty clear that they were familiar with drugs--then it's fairly obvious that the judge is looking at it from the standpoint that, "This may be the first time he's gotten caught, but clearly, he's done this lots of times before." And he'd be right. But he'd be wrong to impose a sentence based on that. Sentence should be based solely on the evidence presented in court.
Now that I have a better understanding of what really happened, though, well, to be honest, most of that still applies. On February 24th, 2004, the DOJ coordinated two separate sweeps of companies selling paraphernalia across state lines. One of those companies was 'Tommy Chong Glass.' TC wasn't the largest dealer of paraphernalia, he hadn't been in business the longest, but he was the most visible. He was also one of the most co-operative. But again, the visibility made him an easy target to make an example of.
I'm not a fan of marijuana use--I think it's a bad idea. I'm not going to get into that (What? Ramblings is missing an opportunity to go down a rabbit trail? Maybe some other time). Here's the thing, though: What constitutes paraphernalia? When I was in the Navy, a coworker of mine got busted because somebody noticed that he had a feather pinned to his hat with an alligator clip (he was in civilian clothes); a "roach clip." They tested the clip for marijuana residue and found none. As far as they could tell, this clip had never been used as a 'roach clip.' Maybe he washed it really good, but I doubt it. I nearly got busted one time because I picked up some trash in a parking lot (being the civic minded person that I am), and included in that trash was an empty pack of rolling papers. I could almost understand if I had actual rolling papers in my possession... Anyway, both of these items, alligator clips and rolling papers, have legitimate and legal uses that have nothing to do with drugs. The prosecutor in TC's case cited the verdict handed down by the US Supreme Court in the 1994 case of Iowa v. Poster-N-Things, which basically said, what would a reasonable person believe that this product was intended to be used for, given the packaging and the way it is marketed? There's a thought-provoking question. Now Tommy Chong Glass didn't just sell bongs, they also sold a home urinalysis kit--in case you had a job interview with urinalysis and you weren't sure if it had been long enough since your last toke--and a chemical that was supposed to remove traces of THC from urine, and a shampoo allegedly designed to remove marijuana smell from hair (won't pretty much any shampoo do that?). Some of these bongs had pictures of marijuana leaves on them (some had Tommy's picture on them). Okay, I would have to agree, that meets the criteria.
But let me ask you this: If I wanted to smoke tobacco in a pipe that had a picture of a marijuana leaf on it, is that a crime? Apparently it is. Let me rephrase: Should it be a crime? (BTW-small rabbit trail--I don't smoke (not even tobacco), and I don't own a pipe. Just thought I should let you know.) Let's look at this another way: What if I were one of those people that believed marijuana should be legal (I'm not), but I was a law-abiding citizen (in other words, not toking, just protesting the fact that I can't, legally), and I wanted various products with pictures of marijuana leaves on them. Do I have to paint the pictures myself, because it's illegal to sell paraphernalia?
Look, I don't think that marijuana should be legalized. I DON'T. But I don't think justice is served by putting people in jail for selling paraphernalia. Maybe if we had lots of prisons sitting half-empty just waiting for people to be convicted, but in some cases, judges are having to reduce sentences because of prison overcrowding.
Just a quick celebrity checklist (what I think):
Tommy Chong--I don't think he should have gone to jail.
Martha Stewart--I don't think she should have gone to jail.
Jim Bakker--Maybe, but it should have been a minimum security prison.
Paris Hilton--Oh, she definitely belongs in jail.
Look, I could see making TC pay a fine, and confiscating all his paraphernalia (I'm not sure I agree with even arresting him, but, at most, he should have gotten the aforementioned).
I'm not a fan of Martha Stewart, but throwing her in jail did not make me feel safer.
Jim Bakker did a lot of things wrong, but, let's face it, who did he hurt (some would say that he fleeced money from a lot of people--but if they hadn't given their money to him, they would have found someone else to give it to; another televangelist probably)? A lot of people felt better about themselves (and felt closer to God) just by watching PTL on TV. Basically he was running a pyramid scheme with his followers (every time he needed money, he would promote something on his show, and people would send money in, and then when they collected on whatever it was he had promoted, then he would have another promotion to cover the cost of the last promotion), but, unlike your run-of-the-mill con artist, Jim Bakker wasn't going anywhere. He just had to keep coming up with new schemes to finance his old ones. Is that a crime? Yes, I would have to say that it is; eventually the pyramid is going to collapse. But the sight of him being led off in an orange jumpsuit and shackles just seemed so unjust. I'm sure some people thought it was better than he deserved. I think that sort of treatment should be reserved for dangerous criminals--ones convicted of violent crimes.
Paris Hilton--got her license suspended for DUI, then got pulled over again, and convicted for driving on a suspended license. Should we fine her? How much would we have to fine her before she pays attention? Let's be honest about it, if you are I were convicted of the same thing, would we be sentenced to *only* 45 days (with a possible 22 days knocked off for good behavior)? And her excuse? She says her publicist told her that she could still drive to work. To work? I didn't know 'The Simple Life' was back in production. Maybe her next reality series will be... Never mind. I'm being hateful, now. But didn't she just make a big deal about how the dumb blonde act is just an act? I'm sorry, give me some time, I'll cool off, and I'll be more tolerant of her. At least they didn't shackle her.
Notice I didn't talk about the ones that didn't go to jail: O.J. Simpson, Michael Jackson, Robert Blake. You know what, though? I'm just not even going to get into that.

Monday, June 11, 2007

What are you smoking?

I just read an interesting quote: supposedly, Tommy Chong said that "The GOP-run media is using 'Parisgate' as a distraction." Now, of course, just because somebody said that Tommy Chong actually said that, doesn't mean that he actually did. If he did say it, it doesn't necessarily mean that he believes it--after all, what have you heard from TC lately, other than his jail sentence for misdemeanor possession (more on that later)? It seems to me that he may be just trying to garner some attention. This link supposedly has video of TC spouting the above quote (but I couldn't get the video to play on my computer): http://hotair.com/archives/2007/06/11/tommy-chong-the-gop-run-media-is-using-parisgate-as-a-distraction/
Anyway, let's examine the statement. If the GOP controlled the media, do you really think that we would be hearing all the criticism in the media about GOP policies? Wouldn't a GOP-run media tell us about how well the war in Iraq is going? Mission accomplished! we have lost a few soldiers in 'training accidents' in Iraq, but nothing serious. Everything is going well. Isn't that the sort of news you would expect?

I think that the basic mistake is that the media (in general) is pushing a particular political agenda. I think that there are individuals in the media that are, but that the media itself is not. If you look at media coverage of our elected officials, generally, in the early days of a given administration, the media gives whoever favorable coverage, but after they've been in office a few months, the coverage starts to get less and less favorable. The coverage that President Bush has gotten lately makes it seem as if the media is controlled by the DNC, but the coverage that President Clinton got during his last days in office supports the GOP-run media theory. A lot of people seem to think that the purpose of a news agency is to report the news. It's not. The purpose of a news agency is to sell advertising. If a news agency thinks that it can sell more newspapers (and thereby get their ads in the hands of more people) by covering Paris Hilton's escapades than by reporting on the war in Iraq, then that's exactly what they are going to do. If a television news program thinks that more people want to hear about Pat Tillman than Rosie O'Donnell, then that's what they are going to report on. Is that fair? No, not really, but that's the way it is.
I got into a discussion a few years ago with a guy that was of the opinion that John F. Kennedy Jr. should not be entitled to more and better search and rescue operations than ordinary citizens. Well, I don't know too many 'ordinary citizens' who get lost at sea when their private jet goes down, but anyway, okay, basically, I agree, a person lost at sea should expect to be looked for, whether they are rich and/or politically connected or not. But I pointed out to him that just because JFK Jr. got more media coverage, it didn't necessarily follow that he got more rescuers looking for him. I explained that usually when somebody goes missing, the media only really covers it locally, where that individual is known, as opposed to JFK Jr. who was nationally known, and was the son (and namesake) of one of the most popular presidents ever. His search and rescue merits national attention, and he ends up getting a lot more media coverage. His response was that he wasn't talking about the media coverage, he was talking about the efforts being expended to try to find him. So I asked him why he thought more effort was going into the JFK Jr. SAR than for Joe Average. His response: Just look at the media coverage.
I'm sorry, but you are never going to get the whole story from the media coverage, no matter who happens to be controlling the media. Even when you have news agencies with editors and reporters that are legitimately committed to reporting the news without bias, when you get right down to it, the organization has to make a profit. If you can't attract people's attention, you can't sell advertising. And if your news offends the sensibilities of the companies that are buying your ad-space, something's gonna give. Sometimes the truth is a casualty of reporting the news.

Friday, June 08, 2007

What Do You Want?

Well, it is time to blog again, and, once again, I am at a loss for words.
The men's group at church is having a fish-fry tonight. As much as I like fish, and as much fun as it promises to be, I find myself really not wanting to go. I don't really have a reason not to go, I just don't want to. I don't even have a reason why I don't want to. I'm going to go; and hopefully I'll have a good time. Maybe I need to pray about that.
It's funny how sometimes what we want and what we need not only don't match, but are directly opposite of each other. Of course, sometimes what we want and what we want are in direct opposition. For example: I want to be built like Governor Schwarzenegger, but I also want to eat like a pig, and lay on the couch and watch TV all the time. I want to be able, at any time, to give an answer of the hope that I have of eternal life, but I would rather take a nap than study my Bible. You can probably think of lots more examples.
I'm going to do a little travelling down a rabbit trail, now (just letting you know). I know a lot of people who want to be spiritual and want to go to Heaven, but they don't want to study the Bible, or they don't want to do any of the things in the Bible. I've had people tell me, "Oh, as long as you're doing your best. God will let you into Heaven." What I'd like to know is, if doing your best doesn't include reading the Bible, then what makes you think any of the rest of that is any good anyway?
Once I had somebody use the 'car wash analogy' on me. What he said was, basically, "If you owned a car wash, and you had an employee that didn't do things exactly the way you wanted, you wouldn't just fire him, as long as he got the cars clean, right?" That makes sense, in and of itself, but let's look at it a little deeper. First of all, you have a lot of chemicals in a car wash. There's glass cleaner, detergent, bug cleaner, degreaser, tire cleaner, and whitewall cleaner. OSHA (Our Savior Has Arrived) will expect any employee at the car wash to be familiar with the safety precautions and interaction warnings of each of these chemicals. If you, as my employee, don't get to know these things, OSHA can, and probably will, shut down my car wash (I am not letting you get my business shut down--besides, I don't want any of my employees to get hurt). Furthermore, although the main objective is to make sure cars get clean, I, as the owner, want to make sure that ALL the cars going through my wash get clean. If Ray normally brings his car through on Tuesday, but this week got something nasty on his car on Friday, and comes in Saturday for a wash, he's going to expect the exact same treatment that he normally gets on Tuesday. For that reason, I'm going to have a checklist made up to make sure everything that supposed to get done gets done every time a car comes through my wash, no matter which of my employees happen to be working that day. That means that I'm going to have some written material at my car wash: The checklist and the MSDS sheets for the chemicals. Each of my employees is going to know these things. If you haven't read, indeed, are not familiar with, the written guidelines of my car wash, then, no, you are not going to collect a paycheck. Having said that, do you really think that God gave us the written material that he gave us just for it to sit on a shelf and collect dust? Granted, God isn't worried about OSHA shutting Him down, or maintaining ISO 9001 certification, but there are things in there that He wants us to know. Isn't it just common sense that we read up?
I read somewhere that the Bible is still the best selling book in America, but that more Americans have actually read the IKEA catalog. I think they were being facetious, but it's kind of a scary thought, just the same.

Thursday, June 07, 2007

Everyday Stupidity

So far this week we have talked about boasting, speculation, and education. What's next?
How about just general stupidity?
Of course, sometimes, general stupidity isn't so much stupidity at all, it's either ignorance, or an ingrained response that doesn't quite fit the current situation.
Case in point: Back in the 70's, I knew a guy that used "The Dry Look" (the advertising was that it was the first hairspray designed for men). Anyway, he normally kept his hairspray on the back of his toilet (on the tank lid). The flush mechanism started acting up, so he moved his hairspray, and took the lid off of the tank. He wasn't able to actually fix the problem, but he did find that it was easier to stop the toilet from 'running' inside the tank than just jiggling the flush handle. You've probably already guessed the next part. Next morning, he's getting ready for work, he sprays his hair, and goes to put the hairspray on the tank lid. That isn't there. Sploosh! That's not the stupid part. As soon as he realized what he had done, he looked around to see if anyone saw him do it. In his bathroom. The guy lives alone. At the same time, that's not really that stupid. Basically, he got double-whammied by two different ingrained responses: 1) He always put his hairspray in the same place, and 2) Whenever he felt he had done something stupid, he looked around to see if anybody saw him.
Another case: My mother worked for awhile for a guy that had a thing about computers. He had one computer in his office, and several typewriters. Anytime he needed a document, he would have one of the secretaries type it up on one of the typewriters, and then he would proof-read and edit it. Once he was satisfied, he would have her type it into the computer, and print it out, so that he could proof-read and edit it again. I'm not sure what his thing with computers was (If it initially goes in wrong, then the incorrect draft might print out later?), but I don't think that it was as much stupidity as just a mistrust of computers.
A friend of mine was working as an RDC for the Navy (RDC stands for Recruit Division Commander and it is the current title for the Navy's version of Drill Instructor), and he had a very quiet, soft-spoken wife. He used to spend long hours trying to instill discipline and professionalism into a group of about 80 Navy Recruits, and then come home to his wife. It generally took him a while to unwind at the end of his workday. Generally it didn't take very long for his wife to say something that he would chew out a recruit for saying (such as "yeah"--and that may sound kind of mickey mouse, but, there are some things that are tolerated, even expected in civilian life that do not fit with a military life-style), and he would respond with, "YEAH? WHAT DO YOU MEAN, 'YEAH?'" Eventually she learned to say, "Don't take that tone with me; I'm not one of your recruits!" Again, for several hours of each day, this would be the correct response. This becomes ingrained. It isn't something that can be simply 'turned off' at the end of the workday (Try untraining Pavlov's dog).
I'd like to tell you about something stupid that I did, but I'm afraid that if I tell you something stupid that I did and then explain it away like I have these other examples, that would create the impression that my whole purpose for this blog was to justify my own stupid act. On the other hand, I don't want to confess to something really stupid and then have it come back and bite me later. That would be really stupid.
Here's one that combines my stupidity with someone else's, and could have caused some severe problems: Years ago, I had a room-mate that liked to set his alarm for 2:00 AM, and then, when it went off, get up and re-set it for 7:30. When I complained to him about that, he said, "Oh, but the most blessed sleep is the sleep you get after the alarm goes off." Soon he started complaining about my alarm going off at 4:00 AM. I'm not sure what he expected me to do about it--quit my job and then not have to set the alarm at all (I'm sure it wouldn't have taken him too long to complain that I wasn't paying my share of the rent). It wasn't like I wanted to get up at 4:00 AM--especially since, a lot of times, I was just getting back to sleep after hearing his alarm when I had to get up. After several bouts of him complaining that I was being 'inconsiderate,' I finally got clever enough to tell him, "Oh, but the most blessed sleep is the sleep you get after the alarm goes off." His response: "I think that only works if it's your own alarm clock." I said, "Exactly." I'm not sure if that just took awhile to sink in, or if he talked to somebody else about the situation, but he continued to set his alarm for 2:00 AM, and complain about my alarm going off at 4, for about three weeks after that, and then, suddenly, no more. During those three weeks, I refused to be dragged into a conversation about it. Whenever he would start in, I just ignored him. Much, much later, it occurred to me that I should have suggested that he set his alarm for 4:00 AM instead of 2, then I could get up and get ready for work when his alarm went off, and he could get his 'blessed' sleep... I bet I could have talked him into that; after all, he really just wanted the psychological effect of being able to turn off his alarm and go back to sleep--I can't believe it really would have made that much difference what time his alarm went off. To be honest, his alarm woke me more effectively than mine did, anyway (although, that may have been a psychological effect also, in that it really made me mad that he woke me up just so he could go back to sleep).
Of course, some of you are saying right now, "Hey, that's cheap! He said he was going to tell us about something stupid that he did, and the story that he told us was mostly about his room-mate's stupidity!" Yeah, you're right. How about that. There was some of my stupidity in there, but, most of it was his. I told you I didn't want to share something that might come back and bite me later... I suppose I could tell you about the time that I got cocky and cut an aluminum rail with a hacksaw after only measuring once (I am a firm believer in the rule, measure twice, cut once); that was pretty stupid, but I got lucky, my first measurement was right.
In any case, this is getting to be a really long post. I'm sure that I could come up with lot's more stupid stories, but I've rambled enough for today. If you really want more stupid stories, I bet you could google, 'stupid stories' and get a bunch.

Tuesday, June 05, 2007

Education

In yesterday's post about speculation, I included some comments on the educational system. Today I would like to address the system itself. I'm speculating, of course.



First off, I want to talk about school vouchers. Some states have a school voucher program. One of the provisions of the "No Child Left Behind" Act (also known as the "No Teacher Left Standing" Act) is to make school vouchers available to parents with children in under-performing schools (another is to allow that student to simply transfer to another school in the same district that has higher scores). I have two problems with school vouchers:

1) If we make school vouchers available when a school is under performing, where does the money for private school come from (or, for that matter, if we transfer a student from one school to another school, where does the school the student is transferred to get its funding for this new student)? Presumably from the underachieving school. Now, if the underachieving school loses money every time one of its students jumps ship in the attempt to get a better education, granted that is a pretty strong motivator to get the school up to speed, but, let's face it, budget was probably a factor in the school's original problems anyway. If you stop and think about it, the school building still has to be heated in the winter (if anything, losing students will increase the heating bill), the teacher's still have to get paid (how many students have to leave before we can fire a teacher? realistically, about 125 to 180 in a given grade), the principal, the secretary, and the custodian all still have to get paid. So where do we cut corners? It's not like they can sell the unused desk and recover the money from their budget that they lost when the student transferred. On the other hand, we can't very well increase the school's budget every time it fails to meet a benchmark--some of our schools would deliberately fail just to get more money.

2) The courts have ruled that school vouchers cannot be used at schools sponsored by religious organizations (This is cited as separation of church and state, in that tax dollars would be going to a religious institution. Personally, I think that the ruling is itself a violation of church and state in that the state is now discriminating against schools based on religious affiliation, but that's a subject for another time). Let's face it, the vast majority of private schools in this country are religious in nature. I could be mistaken, but I think the Roman Catholic church operates most of the private schools, but other churches, as well as temples, and mosques operate private schools as well. If we eliminate most private schools from the list of ones where vouchers can be used, we have severely limited what schools these parents can take their kids to. Are they really going to get a better education there? In most cases, yes, because the private school wouldn't have survived without vouchers if it didn't do its job well, but what happens if the private school suddenly becomes flooded with students from public schools? How long will it take before somebody figures out that if he throws together a building and hires a few teachers, that he can make a lot of money providing sub-standard education to kids just because the local public school stinks?



So what's wrong with public schools? I think that we have too many students in a class. Of course, to reduce class size would entail hiring more teachers, and, in some cases (most cases?), would require adding classrooms. Both of these cost money. This means more tax dollars. We, in general, fight increases in taxes, not just because it's more money out of my pocket, but also because we frequently see tax dollars get spent wastefully. Could we eliminate waste and hire more teachers? That's an idea, but we're going to have to ping on our elected representatives pretty hard to make that happen.

Also, I think that our schools are poorly designed. Let's face it, most public schools are just plain ugly. What does your child think when you send him off to an ugly, inefficient building to learn? Doesn't that send the message that learning isn't important? (so does paying a professional athlete {and possible steroid user} millions of dollars a year, while paying a teacher starvation wages.) We have a lot of old school buildings in this country. They aren't insulated well, and they don't have efficient heating/air conditioning. The buildings themselves are expensive to maintain, but as long as they stand and can be heated, they aren't likely to be replaced, or even re-insulated.

Another problem that we have is textbooks. Many schools are still using old textbooks, because the money's not in the budget to buy up-to-date textbooks. Even then, textbooks are often written by professional writers, rather than by scientists, historians, mathematicians, biologists, or other professionals. Granted, a writer may be better at getting ideas across, but there are a lot of content issues with textbooks because they aren't compiled by people that actually work with the material that should be in the book. What good is it to get the idea across if the idea is just plain wrong?



Mostly, it comes down to money. How much are we, as a society, willing to spend on the education of our children? We should be willing to prioritize. Which is more important to us: Watching an exciting sporting event, or our child's future? Having a federally funded government project in our home state, or having a child that knows the names and capitals of every state? Maybe what we really need to consider is that what nursing home we wind up in may very well depend on how much money our kids are earning, which in turn depends on how good their jobs are, which, in turn, depends on how good their education was...