Monday, June 25, 2007

American Ignorance

There was an interesting survey sponsored by Newsweek--you can look at it here. 81% of respondents at least knew that they didn't know who the Chief Justice of the U. S. Supreme Court was. 28% knew that they didn't know who the Speaker of the House was. 40% knew that they didn't know who the first Republican president was. As Americans, our ignorance is astounding. We should be the most blissful nation on earth.

There were some trick questions in the poll. One question asked when did the Korean War officially end, and included in its multiple choices both '1953' and 'Did it ever end?' Both of those answers could be considered correct. The fact is that in 1953 an armistice was signed, which ended hostilities between the two nations and established a de-militarized zone (DMZ) between the two. This agreement is considered by some to be the official end of the Korean War, while others point to the fact that no formal peace treaty was ever signed, and wars are normally ended by peace treaties. Another asked how many countries have nuclear weapons, but did not offer seven or eight as a choice--the United States, Russia, Great Britain, France, China, India, and Pakistan have all been verified as having nuclear weapons. North Korea claims to have nuclear weapons, however, there has been no detection of radioactive fallout from their tests, indicating that they may have only detonated a rather large conventional weapon. Israel will neither confirm nor deny their nuclear capabilities, but they certainly like for their neighbors to think that they have nuclear weapons. That would make nine the correct (or, at least, most correct) answer. Considerably more people answered five, presumably because only five nations have signed the nuclear non-proliferation treaty (the first five on the above list).

I was surprised that 20% thought that Christianity was older than Judaism--one out of five are not aware that Jesus was born a Jew? At least that means a good chunk of our population don't blame the Jews for the death of Christ... 21% thought Islam was older than Judaism. Wow.

There were a good many things that I did not know: I did not know that Indonesia has the world's largest Muslim population. I could not have told you what year the Internet stock-bubble burst. Did not know the current Dow-Jones average, or the current chairman of the Federal Reserve Board (I had heard some noise awhile back about Alan Greenspan retiring, but I didn't know that he actually had). I was unaware that childbirth kills one woman every minute somewhere in the world (I wonder how many women die from botched abortions?). I could not have named the winner of American Idol this year (and I am surprised and comforted by the fact that 77% of the respondents couldn't either).

Perhaps the biggest surprise was the breakdown of political affiliations: 35% identified themselves as Democratic, 34% as Independent, 25% as Republican, 3% as no party affiliation, and 3% didn't know (just at a guess, I would say many of the 3% who responded 'don't know' would have responded 'Republican' eight years ago). If that breakdown truly represents the national population, then our next president may be an Independent. Perhaps we should pay more attention to Ralph Nader than to John McCain...

Friday, June 22, 2007

Movies

Well, Michael Moore's latest film is about to be released: SiCKO, about the health care industry. I haven't yet quite figured out why he needed to go to Cuba to film this, and I'm not sure that I care. I don't intend to watch it.

From what I understand (let me remind you, I've already said, I haven't seen it, so this may be way off base), this is his push for health care reform. It seems to me that if "John Q" didn't convince you that the health care system needs reform, then this won't either. I don't think it's so much a question of, does the system need improving, it's a question of which direction does it need to go. A lot of people have pushed for socialized medicine. I think that would be a mistake. Rightly or wrongly, our economic system, here in the United Sates, is built on capitalism. In some ways, it's a flawed system, but, mostly, it works. It would be nice if we had a system that worked simply because of people's love and care for their fellow man, but, realistically, we have a system that works on a principle that we can count on: Greed.

Take a minute, and let that sink in. That's really what it's all about. I work a job so that I can pay my bills and buy groceries, etc. If I didn't get paid, I wouldn't come to work. It's that simple. Some people are lucky enough to have a job doing something that they actually love doing (most of us don't), but even those people generally can't afford to work for free. I would imagine that a lot of people get attracted to the medical profession out of a sincere desire to help people, but, let's face it, for many people that desire wears off pretty fast, and then it's the money that keeps them going. Medical school isn't cheap, and a lot of doctors and nurses get pretty burned out by all the things that they have to deal with before their student loans are even paid off.

Let's consider something else: If we socialize medicine, who controls the program? Who decides what surgeries are necessary, what drugs are approved, when life-support is no longer cost-effective? Presumably our government. Think back a few years. I'm betting you don't have to think back very far to be able to think of something that our government made a total mess of. I'm not even going to give you a hint. Think about it. Now think about that same government controlling your health care. That should frighten you. I can understand that you may want to blame your favorite mess on one particular individual. That's fine. You may even feel confident that one person won't have anything to with the socialized health care system. Fair enough. What guarantee do you have that the health care system won't be overseen by someone who is no more capable than the person that you blame for the mess that you thought of? Oh, well, it will be someone from the other party. Do you really think that incompetence is the hallmark of one political party?

By the way, here is a list of other documentaries on the subject (that I also haven't seen):
"A Short Course in Brain Surgery", "Two Women", and "The Lemon" (unfortunately, I don't have links to information about those films).

Thursday, June 21, 2007

Problems With Logic

Some time ago, I read an essay on common problems that people face with logic, or thought processes. I wish I could remember where I read it (or even all of what it said), but it was interesting, and I will try to reproduce as much of it as I can:

Circular logic: circular logic basically starts with an assumption, and then uses logic to prove it true. Of course, if you eliminate the assumption from the proof, then the proof falls apart. For example, I had a man tell me that he had come to realize that baptism was not essential to salvation, that as long as one believed, that was enough. When I asked him how he reached that conclusion, he tld me that he had noticed that every time someone got baptized in the Book of Acts, that didn't get baptized until after they were saved. I countered that I wasn't aware of any place in the Book of Acts that it ever said anyone was saved. He opened up his Bible, and proceeded to show me several instances where individuals made a statement of faith before they were baptized. So I asked him where did it say that they were saved, and he pointed to the verse where it said they believed. If I start with the assumption that all you have to do to be saved is to believe, and then check the scriptural timeline, substituting the phrase 'they were saved' for each time someone makes a confession of faith, then, yes, people always 'got saved' before they did anything else. On the other hand, can you find any instance where someone believed, but didn't get baptized? Okay, let me stop there; the idea is not to argue baptism, but logic. I'm just trying to point out the flaw in his logic.
"Ugly baby syndrome" is the name given to the situation where a responsible person (business manager, church leader, or other similar position) is directed to solve a problem or find a new way to do something. The come up with an idea that seems feasible, but, as the organization devotes more and more money to it, it becomes more and more obvious that this is not the way to go. Except to the person who came up with it. The term comes from the concept that, 'It may be ugly, but it's my baby, and I'm not abandoning it!' Some of these people will go down with the ship, rather than admit that the ship has a design flaw.
Jumping to conclusions, or arriving at a conclusion with insufficient evidence. I actually remember the example used in whatever it was that I referred to earlier: "My car won't start. Rogue clowns must have stolen my spark plugs." Put that way, it sounds ridiculous, but most of us engage in something similar more often than we would care to admit. Something evil befalls me, and a person across the room laughs. What I don't know is the person next to them just told a joke, and they didn't notice what happened to me. If I follow my gut, I'm probably going to confront them in such a way that their bewildered denial sounds less than convincing. And so it goes. The Navy actually has a regulation on the books that forbids speaking a foreign langauge in the workplace (unless you are acting as an interpreter) because there have been problems in the past where two foreign-born servicemen were joking around in their native language, and some other sailor got his feeling hurt, thinking that they were laughing at him.
Biased research: Deciding ahead of time what you want the results to be, before you do the research, and then ignoring any data that doesn't support your conclusion. Sometimes this isn't even done consciously. Ernst Haeckel was a biologist that published a series of drawings (in 1874) purporting to show similarities between species at various stages of embryonic development. It was his contention that theses similarities showed that there were vestigal remnants of evolutionary ancestors that were apparent at certain stages. More recent technology has allowed us to photograph embryos from these different species and it makes it clear that, at best, Haeckel exaggerated the similarities, and, at least in some cases, it really looks like he falsified his data. Realisically, for what? Darwin's theory certainly doesn't depend on such things. Was it to make a name for himself? I suggest that it may simply be a case of him getting careless with data that didn't support his theory. You can read more about Ernst Haeckel here and here. By the way, I purposely linked to pro-evolution web-sites because I'm trying to talk about logic problems, not evolution.

Unfortunately, that's all I have time for now. Until tomorrow.

Wednesday, June 20, 2007

Killing Abortionists

James Kopp has just received a second life sentence for killing Dr. Barnett Slepian 9 years ago. He was already serving a life sentence for killing another abortionist. You can read about it here.
These people puzzle the snot out of me. How can you be pro-life and then be out there committing murder? Kopp claims that he didn't intend to kill Slepian, that actually Slepian was killed by a ricochet, but that several children are alive today because of Slepian's death. So, basically, I didn't mean to kill him, but I sure am glad he's dead. Is he saying that he isn't so much a murderer as just a man with really bad judgment? I was always taught that using a firearm outside of an approved shooting range was using deadly force, even if you weren't actually pointing your weapon at someone. Part of that is the range that firearms have. If you don't hit a target with a solid backing, the bullet could travel a very long way and end up who knows where, potentially killing someone other than the one you were trying to scare. Furthermore, as to his claim that several children are alive now because Slepian is dead, no, more likely, several women had to drive farther to get their abortions than if Kopp had obeyed the law.
Some people, I'm told, support Kopp and believe that he was acting on a 'calling.' CNN doesn't mention what religion Kopp claims to be, but usually people like him claim to be Christian. Does this make sense? I'm following the Prince of Peace, who taught me to turn the other cheek, and I'm out there shooting at people. My Bible says Thou shalt not kill, and, to obey every ordinance of man. I understand that some people think that they are above the law, because God's ways are higher than man's ways, but it was God who told us not to kill (can you think of any Biblical prophet that God instructed to break the commandments of God? I can't). The problem with deception is that, when you're deceived, you don't know that you're deceived, because you're deceived.
There was also a poll recently in which, supposedly, 56% of atheists responded that they felt that Christians were more dangerous that Islamic jihadists. Perhaps people like Kopp are why. Maybe they just don't understand that the jihadists consider any non-Muslim to be an infidel (heck, some of them believe that Muslims in a different sect are infidels). When I first heard that statistic, I was prepared to say that I haven't heard of any Christians flying airplanes into buildings, but, some of these nutbags are just about as bad. I think some Christian fundamentalists would like to see the practice of women wearing burkas to become widespread in this country. Let's be honest with ourselves, though, if the only way that you can maintain is if you have no temptations, then you're really not a very good Christian anyway, now are you?

Tuesday, June 19, 2007

Staten Island Landfill

I was just reading about a new flavor of ice cream called, 'Staten Island Landfill' from a company called '5 Boroughs Ice Cream.' It's vanilla ice cream with brownie chunks, cherries, heart-shaped chocolate crunchies, and fudge. Sounds delicious to me. Almost makes me wish I lived in NYC. I understand that borough president James Molinaro is calling for a boycott of the new flavor. Of course, the proposed boycott has gotten the flavor (and the company) a whole lot more publicity. I don't live anywhere near Staten Island, but I have now heard about this ice cream, and, quite frankly, I want to try it. I can understand that the landfill isn't exactly the biggest source of pride in Staten Island (although it may very well be the biggest anything else), but, you know, if you can't laugh off stuff like that, then maybe you should see about relocating the landfill to one of the other boroughs, or outside the city entirely. Maybe even build a plasma converter.
Have you heard about these things? You can read about them here: http://science.howstuffworks.com/plasma-converter.htm
Anyway, I was also reading about Michael Moore's trip to Cuba. Apparently he took three Americans into Cuba to film a documentary about Cuban health care. He requested permission from the State Department, and received no response, and so just went. I don't know if he had a timetable as far as working with the Cuban government... To be honest, that seems likely. I have a hard time believing that he would just blatantly break US laws without some form of justification. Would the State Department have given him permission, had he waited? Hmm. The administration that was the subject of at least one of his previous films gets to decide whether or not to let him pursue this. On the other hand, even if the administration were inclined to grant his request, I'm sure that there are a lot of considerations (one of which would be his safety. Hmm. Maybe this administration would be inclined to let him go). Did he submit his request in a timely enough manner to get through just the normal bureaucratic red tape? I don't know. It's easy to see that going either way. Now Mr. Moore finds himself in the position that he may end up going to jail over this. Of course, if he does, it means that much more publicity for his film. That's definitely not what the current administration wants. I suspect that Michael Moore is more than willing to play the martyr, if it means more people watch his movie. On the other hand, though, now that said movie is available on the Internet, a lot of people will probably watch it for free. It should be interesting to see Moore's response: On the one hand, he wants people to see his movie--he wants people to be aware of the problem that he went to Cuba to document; on the other hand, he would like to make some money on the film, at least to recoup his expenditures...
It's kind of the same thing though, on the one hand, a new ice cream flavor is getting lots of publicity because somebody doesn't like the name; the other is a movie may be getting a lot of publicity because the filmmaker broke a law to film it. The difference, in my mind, at least, is that the ice cream company is right. Michael Moore clearly broke the law, but, the State Department may be wrong, also. I predict that Michael Moore will not go to jail, simply because the current administration does want him to become a 'martyr' (and maybe because they don't want to have to answer questions about why Moore never got any response from the State Department about his proposed trip). Now, I could (and probably will, someday) get into whether the law should exist. I'm not sure that it should (or that it shouldn't), but, then, if it shouldn't, does that mean that Michael Moore was engaging in civil disobedience? I don't want to think about that. That would make my head hurt.

Friday, June 15, 2007

Does God Really Answer Prayer?

The big news this past week was the death of Ruth Bell Graham, wife of Billy Graham. I just recently heard an interesting quote from her. She said, “If God answered every prayer of mine, I would have married the wrong man seven times.”


I was taught in Sunday School as a kid that God answers every prayer, but sometimes the answer is 'No' and sometimes the answer is 'Not now.' We colored a picture of a traffic light with the green light marked 'Yes,' the yellow light marked 'Wait,' and the red light marked 'No.'


In the movie, "Bruce Almighty," Jim Carey's character is given God's powers for part of Buffalo. This includes hearing and answering prayers. Bruce finds out quickly that there are a lot of people in Buffalo that pray an awful lot. Still being somewhat self-centered, he worries that "this is going to suck up my whole life!" so he simply answers everyone's prayers, "Yes." Soon there is rioting in the streets. And with good reason. (By the way, I avoided seeing this movie for a long time, because it seems to me that Hollywood makes enough fun of religion, and because I think Jim Carey has a bad tendency to go way overboard with his characters.)


There is a quote going around something to the effect that you must be gullible if you believe that God answers prayers, even though he only answers .001% of yours, and the rest of the time, 'it just wasn't God's will.' I think that it's easy to scoff at such things, when you are predominantly looking at quantity, rather than quality. I will admit that most of my prayers are of the "Please let that light stay green until I get through it" variety. And most of those, the answer is a resounding, "No!" Big deal. It's easy for me to look at situations like that and say, "Well, that just wasn't God's will." It's harder, when a loved one is severely sick or injured and one prays for a healing, and the person dies anyway. At the same time, this world would be really overcrowded if God only let people die that nobody was praying for. On the other hand, it's really exhilarating when the doctors have done all they can do, and the church joins together and prays, and that person walks out of the hospital. Granted, that's generally not what happens, but when it does happen, it becomes hard to deny that God answers prayer.


We have a man in our church who, several years ago, had heart problems. His doctor got him on the list for a heart transplant, but it looked like it was going to take awhile. The doctor tried not to talk about what his chances were, but it was pretty clear that the doctor didn't think that he was going to live long enough to get a new heart. We prayed for him as a church. After his next examination, the doctor took him off the transplant list. He said his heart was fine.


I've been healed, myself. I don't really talk about it, because it's kind of silly. To be honest, I was being kind of stupid. But, anyway, here it is: I grew up a very nervous individual. I learned to direct my nervous energy into things that were socially acceptable; things that most people wouldn't find annoying. One of my nervous habits was chewing on the insides of my cheeks. By the time I finally made my personal commitment to follow Christ, I had a line of scar tissue down the insides of both cheeks. One day, I accidentally took a chuck out of my right cheek, about the size of a dime. I suppose I could have gone to the doctor about it, but I was afraid that He was going to pull together the edges of the hole and stitch it up, leaving me with a deformed cheek. Of course, I knew I couldn't just put a band-aid on it. So I prayed about it. The next morning, I woke up with a mouth full of blood. So I prayed some more. And the next morning, I woke up with a mouthful of blood. So I prayed even more. And the next morning, I woke up feeling that something was different. It didn't register right away, but there was no blood in my mouth. When I did realize that I wasn't bleeding, I checked the inside of my right cheek. It was perfectly smooth. Not only was there no hole, but all the scar tissue was gone. I actually tried to convince myself, at the time, that I had not been healed, that I had just healed. After all, it's been three days. But there was a hole there the night before, and it wasn't there that morning. And that wouldn't explain the scar tissue being gone either. It occurred to me that the scar tissue has had years to heal, so I checked my left cheek. The scar tissue was still there on that side of my mouth. Now I know I've been healed. I prayed a little bit more, just telling God that I felt stupid with scar tissue on one side of my mouth. A few days later, the scar tissue on the left side of my mouth disappeared.


So, okay, it's kind of a silly story, it's not nearly as impressive as the guy waiting for the heart transplant that suddenly didn't need it anymore, but this happened to me. How can I doubt that God answers prayer (even if the answer to most of my prayers is "No.")?

Thursday, June 14, 2007

Fathers

It occurred to me that Sunday is Father's Day, so I ought to blog about fathers. I had started another blog that I had intended to post today, but that can wait until next week.

I recently saw 'The Pursuit of Happyness' starring Will Smith as Chris Gardner. I thought it was a very good movie. If you haven't seen it, then let me just say that Chris Gardner is a man that wants to be sure, above all else, that he continues to be a part of his son's life. It struck me the there was a particularly interesting contrast between that role and Will Smith's first acting role, playing a young man without a father in 'Fresh Prince of Bel Air.'

The TV series storyline was basically that he had been, up until the first episode of the show, being raised by a single mother in Philadelphia. His mother's sister had married a lawyer, who had managed to do well, and Uncle Phil now has a house in Bel Air. Mom gets worried that he may not live through his teen years in their neighborhood, but her sister's family has lots of room in a very safe neighborhood. One of the most memorable episodes in the series was one where his father, Lou (played by Ben Vereen), actually did come to see him. When Lou shows up at the house, Uncle Phil (played by James Avery), says simply, "Hello, Lou." James Avery is such a great actor, though, with those two words he conveys the message: "Look, I'm not happy to see you. Normally, I wouldn't even let you into my house. For Will's sake, I'll make an exception. But I'm going to be watching you." The final scene of the show, Lou has spent a lot of time with Will, and ends up disappointing him, and then just leaves. Will turns to Uncle Phil, who has basically been his father for the last four years, and starts explaining why he doesn't need his father. "Ive had fourteen great years without him. I've had fourteen great birthdays without him." etc. Uncle Phil just stands there, agreeing with him, but waiting, like those of us in the audience, for the dam to burst. When it does, Will Smith's line is, "Why don't he want me?" and he collapses into Uncle Phil's arms. I wept when I saw that. To be honest, I'm not sure why. Maybe because I know that things like that really happen, it isn't just TV; maybe because my own father has always been there for me.

I am sometimes surprised when I do something, or say something, and I see or hear my father in it. Obviously, he has been an enormous influence on my life. I can't imagine what it would be like to not have that influence. Sometimes I'm disappointed with myself because I get into a situation, and, afterwords, realize that my dad would have handled it better. I remember when I was about ten, for some reason my father and I went to a special church service. I don't remember what the occasion was, or why the rest of the family didn't come, but there we were. It was a hot day, and the air conditioning wasn't working. The pastor got into his sermon, I don't know, fifteen or twenty minutes, and one of the altar boys let out a sigh and collapsed on the floor. He hit his head on the foot of the altar. I remember thinking that somebody should check on him. As I was thinking that, I became aware that the seat beside me was now empty. As I was thinking that it might not be a good idea to move the altar boy because he might have a spinal injury, my father scooped him up and carried him out the side door to the church office. After some time had passed, my father quietly slipped back into church and sat back down. The sermon had not been concluded yet. Afterwards, I found out that he had called the paramedics, they had come, checked the boy out (I say boy, he was older than I was), put a band-aid on him, and left again (he broke open his forehead when he hit the altar, but other than that, he was fine). I was impressed that Dad knew just what to do. There were at least twenty other men in the service, none of them moved. I suppose it's possible that the minister gave a signal, that I missed, for my father to take care of it and everyone else stay put; I don't know. What I feel, is that if I were placed in a new situation, something I've never encountered before, I would almost certainly react like the other men, and not like my father. Out of all the things that I have inherited from my father, I really wish I had inherited the ability to confidently make the right decision in a strange situation.

Let me just repeat a couple of stories that my father has been known to tell:

One is that a farmer had his tractor break down just as he was about to start planting. He had way too much land, and seed, to do the whole farm by hand, but getting the tractor repaired is going to take some time, and there's only so much time to plant. If he doesn't get the seeds in the ground soon, they won't have time to grow before harvest. He doesn't have the money for a new tractor. In the process of the back and forth, trying to work something out, he notices that his neighbor (who is also a farmer), has finished planting and is putting his tractor away. So he goes to his neighbor, hat in hand, explains the situation, and asks to borrow the tractor. The neighbor considers this, scratches his head, and then says, "Well, I'd like to help you out, but, my rope's broken." The first farmer, crestfallen, turns to go, and then stops, and says, "Waitaminute! What does your rope have to do with you loaning me your tractor?" "Well, nothin', really, I guess, but when you don't want to do something, any excuse is good enough."

(Personally, I would think that, under those circumstances, a farmer would loan his tractor, even to another farmer that he didn't like.)

The second story deals with a little bird that wondered why it is that birds are supposed to fly south for the winter. None of the other birds knew, it was just something that they did. He decided that he would stay 'north' one winter and find out. So September comes, and all the others birds fly south. October comes, and it starts to get a little chilly. November comes, and it's getting worse. December comes, and he decides he's had enough. Flying south, though, he encounters a violent snowstorm. He can't get over it, it's too big to go around it, and before you know it, the poor guy's wings are frozen. He manages a survivable landing in a field in southern Indiana. As he's lying there, he thinks to himself that he's going to die. Then he looks up, and sees a horse coming towards him. It doesn't look like the horse has noticed him. He cringes, thinking that he's going to get stomped, but one hoof hits close by, then another, then another, and another; and the horse stops. Now he is almost directly between the horse's two rear hooves. The horse's tail goes up in the air, and, in much the same way that this little bird has made deposits on new cars all over North America, he finds himself on the receiving end. Now he's laying there, thinking to himself, "What a horrible way to die! I would have been better off staying where I was--at least then I'd just freeze to death; I wouldn't die like this." But as he lay there, he realized that the he was warming up; that he had a 'blanket' that was essentially the same temperature as the horse. As soon as he had thawed out, he pulled himself out from under the horse's gift, climbed on top of it, and began to sing. The farmer's cat, however, heard him singing, snuck up behind him, and ate him. There are a number of morals to this story: 1) Not everybody who dumps on you is your enemy. 2) Not everyone who gets you out of a mess is your friend. 3) Just because you're on top of the heap, it doesn't mean you have to sing about it. 4) If you know that you're supposed to do something, then do it. You don't have to understand why you're supposed to do it, just do it.

Of course, some people would rather just make excuses.