Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Still More Logic Flaws

Another flaw in logic that seems to run rampant is the tendency to believe what one wants to believe to the point of ignoring all evidence to the contrary--or even refusing to examine the evidence for fear of being proved wrong. I think this is related to 'Ugly Baby Syndrome' that I mentioned the first time I blogged about logic flaws, but it isn't quite the same. I do think that is basic human nature--nobody wants to be wrong (myself included). One thing I have noticed, though, the sooner one will at least open up to the possibility that one might be wrong, the easier it is to put the mistake (if it is one) behind oneself and move past it.
Over a year ago, I heard a sermon that mentioned a point that I had never considered: After Abraham took Isaac up the mountain to offer him up as a sacrifice unto God, their relationship was never the same. After service, I had a man want to argue the point with me, saying that in Hebrews chapter 11, verses 18 and 19, it indicates that Abraham had faith that if he did kill Isaac, that God would raise Isaac up from the dead, so, the intended sacrifice shouldn't have affected their relationship at all. I responded that Isaac didn't know that. His position was that it didn't matter if Isaac knew, Abraham did, so it shouldn't have any affect. I tried for some time to get across to him that just because one person knows why they did something potentially harmful to the relationship, it does not by any means show cause for the other person in the relationship to be understanding. He would not (or could not) accept that. This past weekend, the same minister preached a sermon about relationships and mentioned this point again, but went into a lot more detail about how this would have affected Isaac (Unfortunately, my friend that wanted to argue about it wasn't in church Sunday).
This, of course, brings up another logic flaw: at times we will do things, expecting that other people will understand why we do what we do. Other people can't see motivation, they can only see results. If the end result is to push people away, they aren't going to see that the intent was to be helpful. Even in a father-son relationship (or mother-daughter), what is intended as a protective act is often interpreted as a vindictive one.
We have a tendency to develop 'filters' for dealing with other people. If one has been treated badly for a long time, one eventually learns to expect to be treated badly, even by strangers. I know a couple of attractive, twenty-something women that have grown accustomed to the fact that when a young man compliments them on their appearance, that he usually has more on his mind than just being glad to see something that looks nice. As a result, sometimes when people comment on their appearance, they either don't respond at all, or they respond with considerably less enthusiasm than might otherwise be expected. Essentially, they have developed a filter, so that when a man says, 'You look nice today,' even if he means it in the most innocent manner possible, they hear, 'Let's go to bed.' I believe that psychologists would call that filter a defensive mechanism. That happens to be a pretty good one; most guys don't persist long after a reaction like that. There are, of course many other filters, and even types of filters. These all come about from experiences, and the human brain doesn't always notice the subtle differences between the current situation, and the situation that established the filter. There used to be a T-shirt that said, "I know you understand what you think I said, but what you may not realize is that what you heard is not what I meant." I thought that shirt was hilarious at the time, but now that I understand more about filters, it's not nearly as funny--in fact, it makes a lot of sense.

Tuesday, July 24, 2007

Glass Houses

File this one under 'Figure the Odds.'
It has occurred to me that I should probably have multiple blogs, and blog on a different theme on each blog, but I really don't have the time to keep up with one blog as it is... I admit that I think it would be nice, from the reader's perspective, if you could just check 'Religious Ramblings' for my latest thoughts on Religion, or 'Crime Ramblings' for crime stories, or 'Immigration Ramblings,' etc. Maybe when I retire (in about fifty years).
In the meantime, let me take an entirely different tack: In the movie 'Blazing Saddles' (which some of you have probably never heard of), Gene Wilder plays the town drunk, who also happens to be (or have been) the Waco Kid. The Waco Kid, in his heyday, was so well known for being a fast draw and an accurate shot, that people came from miles away just to see if they could outdraw the Waco Kid. Eventually, the enormity of that caused him to 'crawl into a bottle.'
It occurs to me that we, as human beings, have a certain amount of competitiveness built into us. Sometimes it's healthy, sometimes it's not. When you hear about a gunslinger, and just have to know if you're faster than he is (and that sort of thing really did happen), that's not healthy. If you run across someone who is much better at something that you thought you were good at, and it encourages you to practice, practice, practice, until you are really good at it, too (even if you eventually have to accept the fact that you will never be as good), then that's healthy.
Sometimes people will go out of their way to knock someone down a peg. That's not necessarily healthy--although, sometimes, a person does need to be knocked down a peg. Occasionally, someone will get bad press about something that is totally unrelated to their specialty. You've heard statements like, "Einstein was a genius, but he never learned to tie his shoes." I don't know if that's actually true, but what if it is? Granted, it kind of makes the rest of us feel less inferior, but let's face it, everybody has problems; everybody has lapses in judgment.
I asked the question the other day, "Know any perfect people walking around today?" I didn't then, and I haven't met any since.

Monday, July 23, 2007

Us vs. Them

Some time ago, I blogged about common flaws in logic. It has occurred to me since then that I missed the 'Us vs. Them' mentality. Some of that gets blown out of proportion by the media, for example, the 'Red State vs. Blue State' debate. In all actuality, if you look at the actual voting totals for each state from the last two elections, most states were fairly evenly split, with only a few thousand votes tipping the state one way or the other. It isn't that any one state is predominantly Republican or Democratic, most states have a pretty good mix.
I'm not sure if Ross Perot suffered from an 'Us vs. Them' mentality when he made his famous verbal gaffe in 1992, but it definitely sounded that way, and he certainly created an 'Us vs. Them' mentality in his audience.
To some extent, I think that it's human nature. During Saddam Hussein's regime in Iraq, the 'Us' was the common people or Iraq, and the 'Them' was the ruling party--particularly Saddam himself. Now that Saddam has been deposed and executed, there is a new 'Us and Them'--the Sunnis and the Shiites (and to some extent, the Kurds).
Here in the United States, we have had conflicts between the haves and the have-nots, blacks and whites, Jews and Gentiles... The latest, though, seems to be 'Us' that have been here since before 1950, and 'Them' that have not. There seems to be a particular prejudice against Mexicans and Muslims. Of course, most Americans can't tell a Mexican from a Brazilian, or an Arab from a Jew. Newsweek online has four different articles (one, two, three, and four) dealing with the attitude of Americans towards Muslims. One thing that seems clear is that most Americans didn't really pay much attention to Muslim immigration prior to 9-11; another is that we, as a nation, have become suspicious of all Muslims since. IMHO, the Muslims that have immigrated to this country in recent years have, for the most part, been trying to get away from crazies like Saddam and Osama. There have obviously been a few who came specifically for no good, but those would seem to be the exception, rather than the rule. I have heard some talk that the Muslims living in the United States 'scare' people, simply because (the reasoning goes) they must know who the terrorists are, and warned no one. I think the terrorists are smarter than that. They have a pretty good idea that Muslims that have taken up permanent residence in the US like it here (or, at least, they did before 9-11), and that they are here to get away from terrorism. The terrorists aren't going to take any chances by letting on to the American Muslims what their plans are. There's this about it, though, if American Muslims continue to be treated as though they don't belong, or as if they are somehow responsible for the tragedies that have been perpetrated by others flying the same flag of religion, it will make it much easier for them to empathize with the terrorists, and possibly become embittered enough to join the ranks of Al Qaeda or some other collection of nuts.
Would you want to be held responsible for the Crusades? I think most of us realize now that the motivation behind the Crusades was, at best, questionable (and a lot of us think that 'questionable' gives them too much credit). How about the Spanish Inquisition?
Can't we all just play nice? If you are only willing to be friends with people that you agree with 100% on every single political, religious, and social detail, you are going to have a very small circle of friends (I'm guessing you could count them on your thumbs. On one hand). There are always going to be disagreements. In some cases, you may feel that your friends have let you down. You may feel that your society has set you up. But for any given individual, you should be able to find some point of agreement. Once you find something you agree on, then work from there. It may be that the things that you feel most strongly about are the things that the two of you disagree most strongly about, but if you try, you can probably gain some understanding as to why that individual feels the way they do, and you may even learn to respect their opinion, even if you don't agree with it. Somewhere down the road, we have to work out our differences, or we are all going to make a very long trip in a very crowded handbasket.

Friday, July 20, 2007

Charlie Hustle

I'm not much of a baseball fan, so maybe I'm not the best one to express this opinion, but I wanted to publish my opinion of Pete Rose and the Baseball Hall of Fame.
First of all, let me point out that I think gambling in and of itself is wrong. If you think it's okay, and you want to go out and 'have a good time' with it, okay. I'm not trying to tell anyone how to live his life. For Pete Rose, as a player and a manager, to bet on baseball is particularly wrong. I can understand if he felt like he was batting on games that he had no special knowledge, for example, playing for the Reds, but betting on a game played between to other teams that the Reds had not faced yet that season. Does that make sense? If he was betting on a game between two teams that he had recently played against, then he has some knowledge of the strengths and weaknesses of each team. This would be something akin to insider trading.
He denied betting on baseball for years, even after the Dowd Report came out in 1989, but, in 2004, finally wrote a book, My Prison Without Bars, admitting his gambling activities. To a lot of people, that was too little, too late. I can somewhat understand that; it would have been different if he had made the admission ten or fifteen years earlier.
He says that he never bet against his team. I tend to believe him, although, to be honest, it's complicated. Obviously, a bookie isn't likely to take a bet from Charlie Hustle against his own team. That would be foolish, unless he already has a bunch of people betting that the Reds would win, and paying off on Rose's bet would actually mean making more money than if he didn't take the bet, and the Reds wound up winning (the theory being, that if Rose is betting against the Reds, either he knows something that the rest of us don't, or he knows that this is a game that the Reds should win, but that he could prevent them from winning and profit off of the long odds). Of course, Rose could have used an intermediary, but I would wonder why this person has never come forward, although, there could be many reasons).
In any case, it seems to me that the Hall of Fame should be celebrating players' accomplishments on the field. What he did off the field is not so important to his Hall of Fame consideration. He's got some pretty impressive stats, even after you compensate for the fact that, as player-manager of the Reds, he occasionally put himself in the game when he really should have given a younger player a chance. He was only the second player in MLB history to break 4,000 career hits (and, yes, that was before he became a player-manager), is the only player in MLB history to play five different positions in All-Star games... I could go on, but let me refer you to Baseball-reference.com; they factor in all of the different statistics of Hall of Fame worthiness, and produce a number. Several players have been inducted into the Hall with lower numbers than Rose's, in fact, the only non-inductee with a higher number than Rose's is Barry Bonds, who is not yet eligible (and, may not ever be). He's made some mistakes, but so have we all. Do you know anybody walking around today that has lived a perfect life? I don't.

Thursday, July 19, 2007

Computers, Death, and God

There's a bumper sticker out that says, "We are Microsoft. Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated." When things like this and this show up in the news on the same day, I really think that bumper sticker is not so funny. Maybe it's just me, but I don't want ads in my applications, even it does allow me to get free Wi-Fi access.
We now have a computer that can play checkers (draughts in the UK) and never lose, and a car with AI.
I'm curious as to how a goddess can sin. Shouldn't their goddess being telling her priests what is, or is not, a sin?
Meanwhile, a couple of thought-provoking things in Newsweek: I See Dead People, and Rabbi Marc Gellman's take on near death experiences. Rabbi Gellman postulates that research into NDE's is dangerous from both a religious and a scientific standpoint. I have read his arguments, and I have to disagree. I don't see any danger to either. Quite frankly, I do think that it is a waste of time and money, but I fail to see the danger. I don't expect that the research will ever find definitive proof one way or the other about the afterlife. That is a matter of faith. There is the idea of placing objects in the ER out of sight of the clinicly dead individual, to see if said individual remembers seeing them in their recollections of their out-of-body experience. Interesting thought, but a good number of NDE'rs don't report seeing the ER from the ceiling, and most of the ones that do are focused on their own bodies, with some attention given to the medical team attempting to revive them. If someone does get revived, and then recalls seeing the number for Dial-A-Prayer written on the top of the ER room light fixture, is that sufficient proof that they had an out-of-body experience? It would be quite a stretch to consider that proof of life after death. I must admit, I have a certain amount of curiosity as to whether the experiences reported by NDE'rs are real, or simply elaborate hallucinations, but, IMHO, it really only matters to the people who went through it.
I do appreciate the fact that Rabbi Gellman states that Genesis tells us why we are here, while Darwin tells us how we are here, and goes on to say that they do not conflict. I'm not entirely sure that they don't conflict, but they can co-exist. The bottom line is that religion tells us that God made the universe, and then made man; science attempts to explain the process by which God did that. I do think that people on both sides tend to get a little too serious. There has been some discussion as to whether the 6 days mentioned in Genesis are literally six twenty-four hour periods of time. It seems to me, that since God didn't create the sun and moon until the fourth day, that isn't talking about a day in the sense of sun-up to sun-rise. Also note that in 2nd Peter 3:8, the scriptures tell us that, "But, beloved, be not ignorant of this one thing, that one day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day." So, am I saying that creation actually took 6,000 years, instead of six days? No, I'm saying that time, with God, is pretty insignificant, even though, with us, it seems vastly important. 6 days, 6,000 years, 6,000 millennia; it's all the same to God. At the same time, the evolutionists insist that mutations happen randomly, but when a random mutation happens to benefit the species, then the mutant strain becomes dominant. If the mutation is not beneficial, then it quietly fades away. They readily admit that most mutation are harmful. That makes evolution a painfully long process, doesn't it? Quite frankly, the odds against humanity evolving by the process of natural selection would seem to be astronomical, and yet, the evolutionists tell us that this must be the case. Look, it's a theory. Granted, right now, that's the most plausible scientific explanation for how we came to be here that anybody has been able to come up with so far, but it is a long way from being considered scientific fact. Don't get all in an uproar if some people challenge its veracity. I can understand that some people are still upset that Galileo Galilei was placed under house arrest by the church for suggesting that the earth orbited the sun (even though I still haven't found any scripture that contradicts him), but that was a long time ago, by people that didn't like having their beliefs challenged. You should be able to empathize with that.

Wednesday, July 18, 2007

Loosely Related Things

Just a few things that are only loosely related:
First, a municipal building in Pennsylvania burned down, courtesy of the township supervisors. File this one under, "It could never happen to me."
A new life for old cigarette machines, which is good, I think. It's nice that they can be useful again, and possibly even beneficial, not to mention, flame-free.
A man in Washington state has his wages garnished because he buys his cigarettes online. To be honest, I'm not sure what to think of this. I don't like cigarettes, but I think the state's tactics in this case were draconian. On the other hand, they mailed him several notices, and even had a tax collection agent leave a business card at his door; he ignored them all.
Two border patrol officers have been sentenced to lengthy prison terms, ostensibly for shooting a drug smuggler (more here). That seems even more draconian than Washington state, until you read the fine print. It seems that they shot him in the back as he ran away, and then tried to cover it up when they realized that he wasn't armed. Even with that understanding, though, the prison sentences they received do seem harsh. A lot of people are upset that the drug smuggler was granted immunity from prosecution to testify against the border patrol officers, but, let's face it, once Ramos and Compean tampered with the evidence to cover up the fact that they shot Aldrete, they pretty much flushed the case against him, anyway.

Tuesday, July 17, 2007

Animals and Immigration

Several animal stories in the news today: A Joey (baby kangaroo), a panda, a snake, a serval (wildcat), and a monkey. It seems odd to me that so many animals hit the news on the same day.
The town where I live voted on a proposition to have local law enforcement apply to be given special federal deportation authority. Some people are very upset about it, some think it's overdue. New Haven, Connecticut has decided to go the other way, citing public safety as a concern. I can somewhat understand that. Just because a person is in this country illegally, doesn't mean that they should be taken advantage of--enslaved or robbed, with the knowledge and the understanding that these people won't go to the police under fear of deportation. This is a valid concern. I still think that the police have a responsibility to enforce existing laws--including immigration laws. I don't think that enforcing immigration laws should be the number one priority of any local law enforcement agency--violent crime should be. If the victim of a violent crime should happen to be an illegal alien, then the police officer should make every effort to arrest both parties, but it would be somewhat understandable if the victim 'got away,' although that may make it difficult to prosecute the violent offender without the victim to testify against him. In other words, illegal immigrants are criminals, just by virtue of being here illegally, but, the criminals that victimize them need to be taken care of. Even if you care nothing about the immigrants (and you should care about them, they are still people), keep in mind that murderers and muggers will find somebody else to prey on if the illegal aliens are deported.
Some of the objections raised to using local law enforcement supplement ICE is that our local police have been accused of racial profiling in the past, and this may simply give them another tool to harass Latinos. I hope that is not the case, but, to be honest, it seems to me that some of our police have shown some bias against Latinos. From what I understand, the town's position is that if someone is accused of a felony, and there is reason to suspect that they are here illegally, then their status will be checked, and, if it is deemed appropriate, then they will be deported. The Mayor has promised that we are not going to check status of traffic violators. I would assume that to mean that people reporting crimes are not in danger of being deported either.