Showing posts with label questions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label questions. Show all posts

Thursday, April 24, 2008

Creation

I heard a comment the other day that the creation account in Genesis is ‘ridiculous’ because the herbs and grasses and trees were created the day before the sun was. This is true, plants were created on day three, and the sun and moon on day four. That’s an interesting point, and, to be honest, that slipped by me before. On the face of it, that does seem some kind of odd, to say the least. My first instinct was to reply that plants don’t need light every day, just because they were created 24 hours before the sun, doesn’t really mean that there was a problem. That didn’t seem right to me; there had to be a better answer, and not just because I don’t believe that the days in Genesis were necessarily the 24-hour days that we have now. Of course, any of us that have read about people growing illicit marijuana plants indoors under artificial light, realize that you don’t need sunlight for plants to grow, you just need light. God created light on day one…
Another comment about Creation was made that in Genesis chapter 1 it says that on the sixth day God created man, in the image of God created He him; male and female created He them. This would have been two days after God created plants, as mentioned above. But, in chapter two, it says that God created Adam first, and then created ‘the garden’, and created Eve later. Why does Genesis 1 say that God created man and woman at the same time, two days after creating plants, and then Genesis 2 says that God created man first, then plants, and then the woman? Let me point out first that Genesis 1 doesn’t say that God created man and woman at the same time, only on the same day. Granted, it’s declared in one verse in the first chapter, but spread out over several verses in chapter two, which can create the impression that little or no time has passed between the creation of man and woman in the first chapter, while also creating the impression that a great deal of time has passed between the two in the second chapter. Notice that there is no mention of nightfall between the creation of Adam and the creation of Eve (although Adam did sleep—prophecy of general anesthesia?). As far as the creation of plants, chapter 1 says He created the plants, chapter 2 says He planted a garden; that’s not the same thing (ask anyone who’s ever planted a garden). So, chapter 1 gives us a general overview of Creation, but then chapter 2 gives us details about the creation of man.
Side note: I mentioned general anesthesia earlier; of course, God didn’t have to use general anesthesia to remove Adam’s rib, He could have used local anesthesia and kept it extremely local. When I heard about this as a kid, it made sense to me, because I didn’t know about local anesthesia. As an adult, I realize that part of the reason that the surgeons who prefer general is that it keeps the patient from moving around. That wouldn’t be a problem for God, either. So why did God put Adam to sleep? I don’t know, but I’m sure it seemed like the best idea at the time. If I had to guess, my best guess that God knew Adam well enough to know that Adam would have serious issues at watching his side open up, and a part of himself come out, and then watching the wound miraculously heal. It might have given him nightmares for life.
Another criticism: After Adam and Eve had eaten the forbidden fruit, and then heard God’s voice, they hid themselves. God called out, “Where art thou?” What kind of omnipotent God loses track of His creation? How could He not know where Adam and Eve were? Generally, I don’t hear that criticism from parents, because we, as parents, understand that. When we know our children are doing something they shouldn’t, we will frequently ask questions that we know the answers to, to try to encourage them to confess. Just because He asked the question, it doesn’t necessarily follow that He didn’t know the answer. I’ve heard that in law school, they teach prospective lawyers that they should never ask a question unless they already know the answer. God never does, either.

Thursday, March 13, 2008

Questions, questions

Some people are just argumentative; if you tell them that the sky is blue, they want to point out that when it’s stormy, then the sky is really more of a gray color. When you point out that it isn’t stormy, then they say, well, not right now, and not here; but later on it may be, or somewhere else it probably is. If you continue to talk to them, they will suck up your whole day arguing about things that don’t really matter.
Sometimes people want to argue the Gospel. You don’t want to just dismiss them, because it is important, but, a lot of times, it doesn’t really matter what you say to them, they just want to argue. It’s also sometimes hard to tell if someone has a legitimate concern, or if they are just being argumentative.
If someone asks, “Can God make a rock so big that even He can’t lift it?” then it’s a pretty safe bet that they just want to give you grief. I have heard some interesting answers to that question: One guy answered, “God made you, didn’t He?” but that answer requires a little inside information. In the education field (particularly military education) it is generally understood that there are two extreme types of learners (most people fall somewhere in between); there are those who absorb every piece of information you can give them, as fast as you can give it to them (these people are known as ‘sponges’), and then there are those who don’t seem capable of absorbing anything (‘rocks’). Another popular answer is, “Yes, God can make a rock so big that it’s impossible for Him to lift, it, but, then, lift it anyway, because with God, all things are possible.” My personal favorite is, “Yes, God could make a rock so big that even He can’t lift it, but He won’t, because then there would be something He couldn’t do.” That answer usually makes the questioner mad, because he/she didn’t want an intelligent answer, they wanted to be able to say, “See, there’s something God can’t do!” Granted, some people ask questions like that just because they are trying to be clever, but those people generally don’t get nearly as upset.
One good thought-provoking question is, “What do you think Jesus wrote on the ground?” I think that if it were important, then the Bible would tell us what Jesus wrote on the ground. My best guess would be that He wrote down the names of the men who were there holding stones, and He listed some of their more recent and more prominent sins. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if He did not write out dates and times that each of them had been with the adulteress that they were accusing (or, if not her, then someone like her). One suggestion is that He simply wrote, “Where is the man?” in big letters. After all, they said that they took her “in the very act,” I don’t think that she was committing that particular act alone. Did the man get away somehow, or was he right there with them, ready to stone this woman? To be honest, that’s something I’d like to know, but I realize that it must not be important.
In any case, we are instructed to avoid foolish and unlearned questions. It doesn’t really matter if they are argumentative or thought-provoking, what does matter is if answering that question actually helps somebody, even if only in a small way. We don’t have to let people just waste our time, but, we do have to be ready to give an answer of the hope that lies within us.

Monday, January 07, 2008

Silly Questions

Dave Barry once wrote that "a woman is someone who, when asked what is wrong, says, 'Nothing.' A man is someone who, when he asks a woman what is wrong, and she says, "Nothing," believes her.
Really, I think that it is not so much that we believe her. I know that on more than one occasion, I have spent an inordinate amount of time trying to get a woman who was obviously troubled, to tell me what was wrong, only to come to the conclusion that she wasn't going to tell me until she was ready. So, after exhausting all known methods for extracting information, I decided that is was best to go along with the game and pretend that nothing was bothering her. Apparently, women find it considerably more satisfying to lower the boom on someone who appears not to realize that she is upset. I'm not sure why that is, but that understanding can be a real timesaver.
God sometimes doesn't answer right away, either. Maybe that's where women get it, I don't know. Oftentimes, we pray to God, expecting a yes-or-no response, and the answer we get is, "Wait." And we ask, "For how long?" and we get no response. And a lot of times, when the solution (finally) arrives, we realize that God set the answer in motion before we even asked. Is that because He knew that we would, or just that time is meaningless to God? I'm not sure.
You've probably heard the story about the man who had a conversation with God and was asking silly questions:
"God?"
"Yes, my son?"
"How long is a million years to you?"
"A million years to me is like a second to you."
"Oh. (long pause) God?"
"Yes, my son?"
"How much is a million dollars to you?"
"A million dollars to me is like a penny to you."
"Oh. (long pause) God?"
"Yes, my son?"
"Can I have a penny?"
"Certainly, my son. Just give me a second..."
Money is certainly meaningless to God, and I suspect that time is, too. We know that He knew the end from the beginning; some say that it is because He controls everything, but I believe that He has given us freedom of choice. I believe that God knows everything that will ever happen because He is not constrained by the flow of time the way that we mere mortals are. He can see what is going to happen, without guessing, and without manipulating. Oh, don't misunderstand me, God does manipulate things sometimes, but only for the greater good--and, usually, because one of His children has asked Him to.

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

The Bible Under Attack

Some people believe that the Bible is the inerrant Word of God. Some people believe that the Bible is an elaborate work of fiction. I think most people believe something somewhere in between.
I'm not even going to bother with the idea that the Bible is complete fiction. As far as the individual attacks on various parts of the Bible, though, let me put forth some discussion:
There is an organization called the Jesus Seminar, which, judging by the name, would seem to be a Christian organization, but, basically, this is a group of 'learned scholars' who have taken the opportunity to sit down and go through the New Testament, and decide (by a majority vote) which passages are true, and which are exaggerations or fabrications. This is a little like taking a group of people who have never seen a car, and giving them the owner's manual of a Porsche 911, and asking them to determine which parts of the manual are true. These people have never met Jesus, what criteria are they using to judge the veracity of the New Testament? Personal experience? If my experiences are dissimilar to yours, does that make mine invalid?
One common point of discussion (perhaps the word 'attack' is to severe) is that this book or that book wasn't written by the person who's name is on it. There are no written copies of the Gospels that date back to the time of the apostles lives, therefore they must not have been written by the apostles. Just out of curiosity, do we have any of the works of Shakespeare written in his own hand (I don't know, but I doubt it)? If Apostle Matthew didn't write the gospel of Matthew, then who did? Why did they attach Matthew's name to it? (well, okay, I know this one; it would have been to grant legitimacy to the document) More to the point, is there any real reason to believe that the Gospels were not written by Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John? I've heard it said that only one of the (alleged) gospel writers was even an eye-witness; I'm not sure which of the four he's referring to: Matthew and John were both disciples of Jesus, and Mark's position is somewhat unclear (he wasn't one of the twelve, but he may have been a follower, just the same). Luke was definitely not an eyewitness, but he became a Christian shortly after the crucifixion, and wrote down what he knew of the gospel story for the benefit of others. Luke's account shows that he had more than a little understanding of what would be required of an historian. Now, the fact that two of the four gospels are written be people who make no claim to be eyewitnesses at least partially refutes the idea that someone affixed Matthew's name or John's name to their account to add credibility (granted, the fact that Luke's account is accepted, even though he was not there, it doesn't necessarily follow that 'The Gospel According to Saint Arismus' would be accepted, but if Arismus was unsure of how a document written in his own name would fare, he might have attached an apostle's name to it). The other book that is frequently questioned is the book of Hebrews. This book claims to be a letter written by Paul to the Hebrews. Many scholars have compared this book to other Pauline epistles, and have concluded that the literary style is quite different. There is supposition that it was actually written by Priscilla, but she attached Paul's name to it because the early church wasn't ready to accept the writings of a woman. Let me take a little side trip for a moment. Anyone familiar with Shel Silverstein? I believe he is best known as an author of children's books, such as 'A Light in the Attic,' 'Where the Sidewalk Ends,' and 'The Giving Tree.' It's my understanding that these are all excellent books for children (I can't personally vouch for any of them, I haven't read them). Shel has also been a contributor to Playboy magazine, and has published some books with that organization. Now, the question is, do you suppose that Mr. Silverstein wrote children's books in the same style that he wrote for Playboy? The point being, there is more to literary style than just the identity of the author, the same author is going to write differently when his words are being directed to different audiences. Oh, but, you say, Paul wrote all of his epistles to Christians in the early church; where is the difference in audience? The difference is this: the book of Hebrews was the only epistle that Paul wrote to a body of believers that was familiar with Old Testament Scripture. He, having been raised a Pharisee, knew the Tanakh very well, and was able to use a lot more Old Testament references with the Hebrews than he could with any other of the epistles. IMHO, writing to gentiles must have been very much like writing to children--he would have had to have picked his words and phrases very carefully to make sure that no confusion arose due to his cross-culture communication. With the Hebrews, he could actually write what was on his heart, using the existent scripture, and use terms that were familiar to the Jews, drawing on their common upbringing.
Also, some people have brought up the fact that there are 'other gospels' that are not included in the Bible. Some have even made claims that these other gospels are older than the text from which the Bible is comprised. That's simply not the case. It is true that there are other documents out there that claim to be gospels, but they are not any older than Matthew, Mark, Luke or John. Most of the others are incomplete, as well. There is a well-known quote in 'The DaVinci Code' where contrarian scholar Sir Leigh Teabing 'reads' a passage from one of the gnostic gospels, but a good portion of that passage is supposition--the sentence in question is based on fragments of parchment (Dan Brown also pulls a linguistic 'fast one' here, pointing out that the phrase uses the term, 'companion,' which, in Aramaic, is the same word that would be translated as 'spouse.' That's true, but what Brown conveniently neglects to mention is that the gnostic gospels were written in Ancient Greek, which had very different words for 'companion' and 'spouse').
By the way, I don't mean to knock Dan Brown: He is a fiction writer, and, as far as I know, has never claimed to believe any of the things that Teabing espoused in the novel. Quite frankly, I think that by including religious controversy in his book, he helped to draw a lot of attention that the book probably wouldn't have gotten as just another murder mystery. That makes Brown a very clever man.